It is difficult not to be biased in writing this because I intentionally chose an album that I love: Puberty 2 by Mitski. It is “indie” or “alternative” music, but is comprised of a variety of elements from other genres, especially punk, which separates her sound as distinctly, well, Mitski.
[DISCLAIMER]: I’m not sure I buy unto this whole “genre” thing. I appreciate their function in categorizing and talking about music, but there has been too much trouble caused by these useful categorization tools becoming over-glorified devices for gatekeeping music. As Jennifer Lena points out, “genres are numerous and boundary work is ongoing as they emerge, evolve, and disappear” (Lena, pp.7). Genres are loosely defined and change over time, and Lena suggests that debates over the criteria that make or break a genre, “serve not only to sort bands and songs into groups but also to identify those who are aware of current distinctions from those who are outsiders or hapless pretenders” (Lena, pp. 7). People need to loosen the boundaries of genre when critically discussing music, especially for an artist like Mitski, who borrows from many genre sources in writing her “indie” music. The racialized political economy continues to affect music categorization today. As a female Asian American artist, Mitski has been pushed out of the mainstream music narrative, lumped into this non-genre of indie rock that doesn’t get to break into the mainstream of popular music. Her position on the outside of the mainstream parallels that of Memphis Minnie, who was erased from the rock narrative early on. After watching her performance, Langston Hughes wrote, “But Memphis Minnie’s music is harder than the coins that roll across the counter” (Hughes, pp. 4), describing the power her music had to affect people on a deeper level than monetary. As sad as it is, that is the reality that many artists, Mitski included, face today as the mainstream and major labels continue to dictate which genres and who “makes it” in the business. [End disclaimer]
On Puberty 2, Mitski explores the fragile intensity of love and sex from a so often overlooked (especially in “indie” music) female perspective. In this exposé of female sexuality, Mitski is the active character, the one seeking and enjoying the sex rather than as an object of male enamorment. This album largely focuses on lyricism strewn with cutting and emotional imagery, which sits atop the platform provided by the instrumentation. Because of this, some of her songs, like “Once More to See You” and “I Bet On Losing Dogs”, are instrumentally simple for the majority of the song. But she still drags raw emotion from these songs, reminiscent of how blues artists used vocalization to draw the listener in to hear their (often lyrically repetitive) stories.
Her blend of musical styles is risky, but comes together in ways that keep the listener engaged, captivating their emotions through their ears. On “Once More to See You”, Mitski strips down the beats of the 60s groups that were derived from the clave to command the song’s bass and drum lines, layering background vocals and synthesizer to yearn for a lover once more. With scratching, frantic strumming, static buzzing, and vocals progressively moving toward spitting the words out viciously, “My Body’s Made of Crushed Little Stars” borrows from punk style. In addition, the lyrics express the artist’s perceived stagnance in her life as compared to her desires to see the world, utilizing work-life metaphors to scream about how she wishes she were dead: “I should tell them that I am not afraid to die… I work better under a deadline… I pick an age when I disappear”.
AND NOW! Your Best American Girl: The platform Mitski uses to discuss the tradeoffs she makes in her personal life as an Asian American woman, grappling with more than just unrequited love.
Mitski’s work doesn’t quite fit into the usual love and hate narrative that (white male) rock artists do. We live in a society that has been deeply affected by Rockism for decades, and Mitski exploit the stolen sounds of rock in her own critique of white male behavior on “Your Best American Girl”. In her punk style, Alice Bag transforms cancíon ranchera’s estilo bravío, which Habell-Pallán describes as, “the wild and rough vocal aesthetic in which women sing with aggressive, fearless, and bold expression, appropriating so-called masculine traits” (Habell-Pallán, pp. 250). Mitski uses similar transformations of estilo bravío throughout the album. Although “Your Best American Girl” starts as a slow, almost lullaby to an unrequited love, the songs builds up to the chorus in volume and instrumentation. Once she reaches the chorus, she employs these bold vocalizations in estilo bravío, singing, “Your mother wouldn’t approve of how my mother raised me / But I do, I think I do / And you’re an all American boy / I guess I couldn’t help trying to be your best American girl”. In this chorus, amplified vocals and electric guitar screeching with feedback crash together in an emotional exclamation of the artist realizing that no matter how hard she tried, her heritage will never let her be that idealized version of an American girl that her love wants.
A large part of Alice Bag’s performance style is her stage presence, her “jerks, jumps, and twirls” and “frenzied dance” as she projects her raw energy to the crowd from the stage (Habell-Pallán, pp. 254). When I saw Mitski, she moved to convey the energy of each song. While her music and stage persona are not exaggerated to the extent of Alice’s, she carries that connection to the audience. When I saw the clip of a live performance of “Gluttony” in class, it reminded me of Mitski’s performance of “Drunk Walk Home” from her album prior to Puberty 2, Bury Me At Makeout Creek, as shown in this clip: https://youtu.be/0O0RboqC0So?t=116. I love how Mitski performs this song. On the studio recording, Mitski screams over the beats; it’s raw and full of emotion, just like Alice’s performances in estilo bravío. In the clip, she gives the audience space to unleash their own screams while she carries that raw energy in her turbulent movements across the stage. Mitski is not Your Best American Girl. She is so much more.
References
- Habell-Pallán, Michelle. “Death to Racism and Punk Rock Revisionism.” Pop: When the World Falls Apart: Music in the Shadow of a Doubt, 2012, pp. 247–270.
- Hughes, Langston. “Music At Year’s End.” Chicago Defender, 9 Jan. 1943.
- Lena, Jennifer. “Music Genres”. Banding Together: How Communities Create Genres in Popular Music, pp. 1–26.
Critical ModelS